See More Results
Home > Movies > Underrated Movies > Underrated Movies: “Red State” (2011) – Horror/Action
Image source: Wordpress

Underrated Movies: “Red State” (2011) – Horror/Action

For personalised movie suggestions go to itcher.

Andy McKendry itcherAs a big fan of Kevin Smith’s work, ‘Red State’ came as something of a surprise. Its tale of bigoted fundamentalism is a long way from the generation X slacker convenience store set story in ‘Clerks.’
~ Andy McKendry

‘Red State’ (2011)

Image Source: Impawards

Director: Kevin Smith
Writer: Kevin Smith
Starring: Michael Parks, John Goodman, Melissa Leo, Michael Angarano, Nicholas Braun, Stephen Root, Anna Gunn
Synopsis: Kevin Smith’s ‘Red State’ tells the story of three young men lured by the promise of sex into the clutches of a group of homosexual hating Christian extremists.
Guns, Crosses, and Religion

Kevin Smith is a director known for his comedy writing. There was the successful New Jersey cannon with titles like ‘Clerks’, and ‘Clerks 2’, and underappreciated movies like ‘Mallrats’ and ‘Chasing Amy.’ But it seems that the filmmaker has opted to explore other genres with ‘Red State’, and then more recently with ‘Tusk.’

‘Red State’ sees Smith leave behind his slacker orientated writing and instead dive into the murky world of religious extremism. The narrative follows three high school boys who are lured with the promise of sex to a remote trailer. Things are far from pleasurable however and they find themselves drugged, captured, and held hostage by a local Westboro Baptist inspired Christian cult.

Led by charismatic Pastor Abin Cooper (Michael Parks who appears in Smith’s later film ‘Tusk’ in a similar role) the church is hell bent on executing the three young men for their immoral desires.

Gun and a Bible

One of the better elements of Smith’s film is its adherence to genre conventions. Smith tells a convincing horror inspired tale and the opening half is claustrophobic, hopeless, and depressing with its articulation of narrow minded and bigoted beliefs.

Our trio of teenaged captives are our eyes and ears into this world and their terror is infectious. Smith’s narrative is clever as it shows the unreasonable demands and the troubling ability of ardent believers to impose their ideology on others. This prompts audiences to experience a tense and uncomfortable awareness that it’s unlikely that these kids will get out alive.

‘Red State’ is similar to other great underrated movies from Kevin Smith with its reliance on wordy dialogue and clever conversational scripting. After the verbose opening half of the movie however things descend into much more conventional action movie fare.

Messy Narrative Arc

‘Red State’ isn’t a great movie but it does have fun with its source material. It opens on a sort of socio-political note, with commentary regarding the influence of religious extremism on society, and the role of free speech. But then it descends into a basic sort of survival horror movie, before finishing up with a traditional action movie third act.

It’s unfortunate that ‘Red State’ doesn’t adhere more to one genre and its conventions. Instead the story sprawls and doesn’t always function clearly. Smith seems quite happy to use stereotypes to progress the narrative and often the characters come across as two dimensional and lacking in definition.

The Good, the Bad, and the Weird

Fans of Kevin Smith may feel confused by ‘Red State.’ It’s not exactly a comedy, although it is a funny satire at times, and it functions as a sort of political comment on the role of extremism in Western society. But it’s also one of the best underrated horror action movies of recent times, and it shows that Smith is a versatile filmmaker.

There’s an eclectic cast too. ‘Breaking Bad’s’ Anna Gunn makes a small appearance, Stephen Root of ‘Office Space’ plays a closeted gay sheriff, and John Goodman stars as a federal agent. Collectively they add a degree of celebrity to what is ostensibly an indie film.

The third act contains some more subtle political imagery. A shoot out occurs between the Christian cult and the federal government and the officers are given orders to kill every member of the congregation. It’s a comment on the siege at Waco, and it ironically reminds audiences that extremism comes in many forms.


Kevin Smith’s Pop Culture Politics

‘Red State’ is a palatable movie and one that features slick and compelling narrative choices. At times the editing is messy, the action often over the top, but the core of the film, and its story of bigotry, is one that is endlessly contemporary. This is a Kevin Smith movie and it just so happens to be an action/horror hybrid with a political core.

It shouldn’t work as well as it does but ‘Red State’ shows that Smith is a talented filmmaker ready to explore other genres and conventions. If you enjoy this film then its worth watching Smith’s later horror hybrid ‘Tusk.’ In both films Smith employs his usual sarcastic dialogue but within different parameters to his ‘90s slacker fare. ‘Red State’ is helmed by great performances, it contains a story that sparks with political relevancy, and its narrative is both funny and prescient.

Have you seen ‘Red State’? Let me know your thoughts with a comment below.

I’m a writer. It’s what I do and what I′ve always done. As a child I wrote on walls with a crayon. Now I write for websites. I write for my blog where I post reviews of films, TV, and occasionally write short stories and I also run a writer and illustration collective. Whatever I do involves words, and plenty of them. I’m an avid cinephile, a screenwriter, and I love telling stories. I have an MA in Professional Writing from Falmouth University, UK, and I work on a freelance basis and drink far too much coffee.
[thrive_leads id="105464"]

Find out what the community are loving on the itcher app right now.


Still looking for a
movie to watch?

Rate 5 movies and we'll find your next favorite one. For FREE.